Skip to main content

New Market, established 1796 in Virginia’s Shenandoah Valley and settled largely by German Lutherans and Mennonites, was home to Our Church Paper, a Lutheran weekly published from 1873-1905 by Henkel & CO.’s Steam Printing House. Founded in 1806 by the Reverend Ambrose Henkel who, according to A History of Shenandoah County, got his start in the printing business when in 1802, at the age of 16, he walked to Hagerstown, Maryland from New Market to apprentice with a printer by the name of Gruber, who was known for almanacs.  Shortly thereafter he purchased his own press and “hauled it up the valley to New Market” where he set up and began printing a German newspaper called The Virginia and New Market Popular Instructor and Weekly News.  From 1806 to 1925 the press was operated by various members of the Henkel family, printing works in the interests of the Lutheran church.

Our Church Paper was perhaps the most well-known publication by the Henkel press. The paper was “devoted to the interests of the Evangelical Lutheran Church” and offered ”articles of faith and doctrine, it will contain much of admonition, besides matter of general interest to the family.” The first page was always a printed sermon, followed by local and national news of particular interest to Lutherans on pages two and three, and then a bounty of recipes, home remedies, household wisdom and light humor on page four.

From that last page today’s reader can get a sense of how it was to run a household around the turn of the last century. It certainly wasn’t easy; take for example the article on achieving the perfect cup of coffee at the top of the page. We can take for granted modern food processing and household improvements such as precise temperature control on ovens, refrigerators, and things like detritus-free, “granulated” sugar, but back in 1874, sugar had to be “sifted”.  Inspired by historic cooking blogs like The Kitchen Historic, and general curiosity about how people once lived, I set out to bake something from Our Church Paper last week and share the results here.

After much deliberation and scrolling through microfilm I settled on “Chocolate Biscuits” because:

  1. They had only 3 ingredients
  2. I had all 3 ingredients on hand
  3. They didn’t sound horrible
  4. They are mostly chocolate

The end result was declared by VNP staff to be “not that bad”, “pretty good”, “ok”, and reminiscent of some unidentified cookie from our past, but I am still unsure as to how they are supposed  to look or taste.

Chocolate Biscuits (adjusted by trial, error, and googling)

When adjusting historic recipes it is important to keep in mind that much has changed.  Online conversion calculators are helpful when converting recipes measured in weight to the cups and spoons we are used to today, unless you have a kitchen scale.


  • 1/2 cup unsweetened cocoa powder or grated baking chocolate
  • 1/2 cup granulated sugar
  • Egg whites


  • Preheat oven to 325 degrees (determined to be a “moderate” oven after some research)
  • Combine cocoa powder and sugar in a bowl
  • Add well-beaten egg whites one at a time until a “paste” of some sort is achieved (mine was too wet but still turned out).
  • Plop on a greased cookie sheet about an inch apart and bake for about 15-20 minutes or until desired texture is achieved.  (I think the texture should be somewhere between Oreo and Meringue.)

Inspired to recreate a little historic cookery?  Curious about 19th century home remedies for warts?  Vintage laundry enthusiast?  Try these ideas at home:

Natalie Draper

Former Virginia Newspaper Project Intern


  • Leonore says:

    I really like it when folks come together and share opinions.
    Great blog, keep it up!

  • Shelia says:

    Wonderful blog! Do you have any helpful hints for
    aspiring writers? I’m planning to start my own site soon but I’m a
    little lost on everything. Would you advise starting with a free
    platform like WordPress or go for a paid option? There are so
    many options out there that I’m totally confused .. Any
    suggestions? Thank you!

    • Kelley says:


      Thank you for the compliment on the blog—we’re always happy to hear that people enjoy some of our posts! WordPress is very user friendly and versatile. I would definitely recommend it, although I should add that we do have an IT department to help out whenever we have questions. I think it would be a good option to start with and if you discover that you feel limited in any way, you can always try something else out. I know a lot of bloggers like Tumblr as well.

      Happy writing!

Leave a Reply